The Tenth Inning
 The Tenth Inning Blog
Periodically, I will post new entries about current baseball topics.  The posts will typically be a mixture of commentary, history, facts, and stats.  Hopefully, they will provoke some  of your thoughts or emotions. Clicking on the word "Comments" associated with each post below will open a new dialog box to enter or retrieve any feedback.
Why would anyone not want to adopt the universal DH?

Ever since the American League adopted the designated hitter position in 1973, a lot of hopeful fans have wondered when the National League would follow suit. Now, 48 years later, a lot of fans are still asking when the senior circuit will finally get on board.

When MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred implemented the universal DH rule last year during the coronavirus pandemic to help reduce risks for NL pitchers during the shortened season, it was assumed the situation would provide the impetus for being incorporated permanently across both leagues.

However, according to MLB insider Ken Rosenthal, Manfred issued a letter advising teams to plan the upcoming season without the universal DH. The National League are probably okay with this direction for now. They did not have much of a chance to plan their 2020 rosters for utilization of a DH and consequently did not get the appropriate type of players to fill the role. For example, according to Call to the Pen, three of the most-used National League DHs in 2020 failed to hit above .200 and six failed to slug .400. On the other hand, the best DH in the National League was Marcell Ozuna, who led the league in home runs and RBIs. Where would the Atlanta Braves have finished without him last year?

There used to be a contingent of baseball fans who didn’t want the National League to embrace the full-time DH role. They were generally part of a group of “traditionalists,” who wanted to keep the game the same as it was played in the ‘40s and ‘50s. By the way, they also didn’t like league expansion, livelier baseballs, and other changes in the game.

But nowadays, why would anyone not want to see the universal DH fully used throughout the game?

Here are some of the main benefits of the DH.

Forget tradition. There would finally be consistency between the leagues for 100% of the games, not just the interleague games.

It provides an opportunity to extend some of the older players’ careers. A prime example of this is Twins’ DH Nelson Cruz, who is still a top slugger at 40 years of age and does not have to play in the field.

There’s not much strategy in having National League pitchers bat, since they are usually an automatic out. Not every team has a pitcher like Madison Bumgarner, who can be a real threat at the plate. However, for every Bumgarner, there are 50 Yu Darvishes, who can’t hit a lick. Eliminating the pitcher as a batter is more in keeping with today’s offensive-minded game.

The DH gives managers more flexibility in lineups, especially if they have an abundance of good hitters. Multiple players can be moved in and out of the role, including defensively-challenged players. As a result, the quality of play in the field improves.

Teams wanting to trade a designated hitter have more options if NL teams are in play.

One of the downsides for teams with a good DH is they cost more. The average player signed by an American League team to be its primary DH got $13.65 million. That was three times the average $4.35 million salary for all positions. Six of the 15 primary DHs were paid in excess of $20 million, topped by Detroit’s Miguel Cabrera at $30 million. Seven were the highest paid players on their team.

So, what’s Manfred waiting on? More than likely, the matter won't be resolved permanently until the next Collective Bargaining Agreement is signed. That probably won't happen until before the start of the 2022 season. The Major League Baseball Players Association will likely want to see rosters expanded to allow for the permanent DH across all teams.

Ever since New York Yankees’ Ron Blomberg became the first DH in major-league history in 1973, it’s been somewhat incredible it has taken so long to be adopted throughout all of baseball. Wait til next year.

Add a Comment

(Enter the numbers shown in the above image)